Demystifying Switching from iPhone to Android

I seem to have read one too many of those “complete iPhone fanboy tries converting to Android” articles today. I decided I’d spend my lunch hours blogging about a few points that seem to always be missed when iPhone users try Android and dismiss it because it doesn’t work like their Apple product. Here are some of the common arguments:

1. It doesn’t work with iTunes!

The most glaring thing I see written and discussed is media sync. When an iPhone fanboy (I’m going to shorten this to iFan to save space) plugs in his Android phone and nothing happens, they always seem to be confused about what to do next. While iOS devices are limited to iTunes for downloading content, Android OS offers many great options for syncing content:

  • Manually move content using the Android phone as a USB drive (yes, it’s legal, and yes, there is file system access)
  • TuneSync – wirelessly sync with your existing iTunes library
  • BeyondPod – wireless podcast syncing over the air – no computer required
  • DoubleTwist – iTunes imitator which works with Android – limited

I personally use BeyondPod to grab all of my podcasts every night. It does it automatically, and it does it extremely well. I don’t have to do anything but listen to my podcasts.

2. App “X” isn’t available/as good on Android

Great, then why would you switch? Seriously, if you depend on one app, and it’s bad or not available, don’t consider the switch. There are crapps on both platforms, and some real gems. Slingplayer on Android is 5x better than on iOS. Facebook, not so much.

3. The keyboard is better on iPhone

I would agree that the iPhone keyboard is the best soft keyboard out there. However, it’s limited in functionality, and it only allows one method of input – tapping. Android’s voice input is available system wide, and it works very well. With the recently released Google Actions, you can press one button and send a text, email, or search without any further screen taps. Also, if you tried Android and didn’t use Swype, you missed out.

4. Visual Voicemail isn’t on Android

This goes back to my earlier point – you can’t use Android the same way you use iOS. iOS has VVM, Android has Google Voice (and voicemail). It works great, is very well integrated, and, in addition to visual voicemail, will actually *gasp* give you speech to text translations of your voicemail (sometimes with hilarious results).

5. I’m not a big Google Services user

If you’re not using Google Services, Android may not be for you. Much of the magic comes from the power of Google, and trying to use it without that magic is like trying to use iOS without iTunes. Explore things like Google Voice. Save on your texting plan. Use a GV number just for selling things on Craigslist. Organize all your contacts in the cloud. Share your calendar with friends, and be able to add things to your spouse’s calendar.

6. I don’t want/care about/need Flash

Great. Don’t install it. Or, set it to “On Demand”. It’s nice to have, and comes in handy. HTML5 may be the future, but we’re not there yet. I personally love being able to access Flash content on an as-needed basisi.

7. The iPhone screen is SOOOO NICE!

No question about it – that Retina screen is great. However, you were using a washed out 320×480 display for the last 3 years. That screen is also stuck at 3.5″ with no hope for anything larger. Android devices offer a variety of screen sizes and resolutions. Choice is nice.

Here are some other things iFans completely neglect in most of their “switcher” reviews:

  • Google Voice
  • Gmail integration
  • Google Navigation – how can you miss this?
  • Voice Search/Actions
  • Widgets
  • Notifications – seriously, iOS needs serious work in this department
  • Social media integration
  • 24 hour Try-before-you-buy Market policy
  • File system access
  • Cloud backup
  • Apps not tied to Apple’s review process – this can be a double-edged sword, but being able to try out programs from outside the market is a huge plus in my book
  • Barcode scanner

There is no doubt that the iPhone has changed what consumers expect from their mobile devices. However, that doesn’t mean that the way Apple envisions your mobile device experience is always the best way. If you don’t hate AT&T’s service, and you’re happy with your iOS device, it’s ok to keep using it. However, reality is that there is a lot of competition in the mobile space, and if you look up from your Retina screen for a second, you’ll see some cool things Android does that iOS doesn’t. Dismissing these things is a bad idea, since you might find utility in the things I listed above. Don’t be like Steve Jobs and say you’ll never need those things because I guarantee that once iOS gets them, you’ll be change your mind like the iFans who suddenly LOVE background apps.

One final word of advice for “switchers”:

Don’t write your article like you’re the shrew who can’t be tamed. Nobody cares if you didn’t switch :-)

TuneSync:

BeyondPod:

Nexus One vs iPhone Screen Comparison

There has been a lot of discussion about the AMOLED screen in the Nexus One and how great it is inside, but how it sucks outside in sunlight. I happen to own both an iPhone 3Gs and a Nexus One, so I decided to do some comparison shots.

The pictures below are all taken with both screens set to full brightness.

These outdoor pics are taken in full sun at around 6pm.

Outside, different homescreens

For these next shots, I took a screenshot from my N1′s homescreen, and copied it to the iPhone so I could display it using the iPhone photo gallery.

Outside, same homescreen

The Nexus One’s AMOLED screen really excels inside as you can see in the comparison shots below (N1 on the right):

Inside, minimal light, full brightness

This closeup really allows you to see the pixels on the iPhone screen vs the smooth, high-res screen on the N1:

Feel free to draw your own conclusions. I don’t see a definitive disadvantage with the Nexus One screen outdoors, and I’ve been using it full-time for the last month. On the other hand, the iPhone 3Gs screen is very washed out and lifeless at high brightness levels. Yuck.

A Peek into 4th Gen iPhone?

After digesting all of the available information on the newly announced Apple iPad, it’s becoming pretty apparent where Apple is going with their strategy. Even though Mac has seen huge increases in Mac/Macbook sales, they need another step in order to get the average consumer to make the leap into a $1000 sale.

In comes the iPad, an purported $499 “tablet” that really doesn’t offer any compelling advantage over the iPhone/Touch. What this will enable Apple to do is lead consumers from their phone to a larger experience in the “tablet” which will eventually lead them to a full-fledged laptop. However, this isn’t the interesting part of their strategy.

If the conjecture that the iPad is “just a big iPhone” is true, then shrinking the iPad back down to iPhone size could very well give us a good indication of what we’re going to see this June. Most likely the important piece of the iPad is actually Apple’s first foray into chip making, the A4. Imagine the A4 processor stuffed into an iPhone with all of the visual queues of the iPad. Not only is this exciting to me, but it makes perfect sense.

The iPad now is in a niche market, but since all of the software will be resized to fit the larger screen, we could now very likely see the much anticipated larger screen for the iPhone 4G (iPhone HD?).

If iPhone 4.0 bring along a slew of long awaited changes such as background processing, revamped interface/lockscreen, bluetooth keyboard support, theming, 5mp camera, and other things that make jailbreaking so popular, we can now add to our list the high resolution screen along with an aluminum case. If Apple can figure out how to make the iPad’s antennas work with the aluminum shell, hopefully they can figure it out for iPhone 4G. Seriously, who likes the glossy case on the current 3G/3Gs?

This is a Photoshop of the iPad which I’ve resized and incorporated some changes to try and demonstrate how the next-gen iPhone could look if Apple continues the revamp. It would only make sense because the rest of their product line has the same theme.

Was I right? I guess we’ll find out in June.

Please note that this is a Photoshop render I did based on the iPad artwork available from Apple.com/iPad. It’s not the real thing (yet).

Griffin Elan Graphite iPhone Case

I’ve been using a cheap eBay case for my iPhone 3GS for the last several months. It works, and does its job, but it’s not the flashiest case I’ve ever seen.

After seeing several friends on Twitter buy this new case over the last few weeks, Michael Manna’s video review pushed me over the edge and I picked one up at the local Apple store last night.

carbonback

carbontop

At $34.95, it’s not the cheapest case, but it really sets off the look of my 3GS and the fact that it’s dockable is a plus as well!

iPhone 3G[S] jailbroken at 3.1.2

sadmacI finally got around to upgrading my iPhone to 3.1.2 – I’ve been at 3.0 since I bought my new 3G[S] a few months ago. Unfortunately it wasn’t all roses for me.

Take 1 - Initially everything seemed very simple – using pwnage tool, I built a new ipsw which included some custom packages. I restored to that new file, and then restored my backup. There was evidently an issue with one of the packages because my springboard kept crashing.

Take 2 – I built a new firmware and didn’t include any custom packages. That restored fine and all was well…except for my visual voicemail. Apparently the MMS hack I loaded a while back was interfering with the new carrier bundle. After some help with @nutzareus I determined that the only way to fix this was to a fresh restore without my backup.

Take 3 - all is now well. I restored the custom firmware and manually set up all my apps, photos, and settings.

Jailbreaking isn’t always a bed of roses, but the stuff I can continue to do with my phone is amazing, and makes it worth the hassle. Besides, I like having a fresh start every once in a while.

Expect more commentary on the Simulcast tomorrow night.